No. 012 · Clock Room
The Root That Expired
· a long tail on old devices
Impact 7.0/10
- 1An old root certificate reaches its long-announced expiry date
- 2Modern systems use the newer root and don't notice
- 3Old phones, old OpenSSL and embedded devices still trust only the old one
- 4TLS handshakes start failing on those clients
- 5Fixes range from config changes to buying new hardware ✕
An expiry date years away is still a date. Put it in a calendar.
Source: Let's Encrypt announcements, 2020 to 2021
Impact
Five dimensions, 0 to 10 each. The overall 7.0/10 is their average. How impact is scored
| Dimension | Score | Basis |
|---|
| Reach | 8 | Old phones, old OpenSSL and embedded devices, worldwide |
|---|
| Duration | 10 | A long tail on old devices |
|---|
| Loss | 2 | Some devices had to be replaced |
|---|
| Recovery | 9 | From config changes to buying new hardware |
|---|
| Cascade | 6 | TLS failed for the sites and services those clients used |
|---|
Let's Encrypt root expiry, September 2021. Duration: a long tail on old devices. 5 hops from the first change to the failure.
See this exhibit in the 3D hall