No. 012 · Clock Room

The Root That Expired

· a long tail on old devices

Impact 7.0/10

  1. 1An old root certificate reaches its long-announced expiry date
  2. 2Modern systems use the newer root and don't notice
  3. 3Old phones, old OpenSSL and embedded devices still trust only the old one
  4. 4TLS handshakes start failing on those clients
  5. 5Fixes range from config changes to buying new hardware ✕

An expiry date years away is still a date. Put it in a calendar.

Source: Let's Encrypt announcements, 2020 to 2021

Impact

Five dimensions, 0 to 10 each. The overall 7.0/10 is their average. How impact is scored

Reach8Duration10Loss2Recovery9Cascade6
DimensionScoreBasis
Reach8Old phones, old OpenSSL and embedded devices, worldwide
Duration10A long tail on old devices
Loss2Some devices had to be replaced
Recovery9From config changes to buying new hardware
Cascade6TLS failed for the sites and services those clients used

Let's Encrypt root expiry, September 2021. Duration: a long tail on old devices. 5 hops from the first change to the failure.

See this exhibit in the 3D hall