No. 010 · Cabinet of Wrong Numbers
Pounds, Meet Newtons
· a 10-month trip, lost on arrival
Impact 6.0/10
- 1Ground software reports thruster impulse in pound-force seconds
- 2Navigation software expects newton-seconds
- 3Every small trajectory correction is off by a factor of about 4.45
- 4Orbiter arrives far too low over Mars
- 5It is lost in the atmosphere ✕
Units belong in the interface contract, not in someone's head.
Source: NASA Mishap Investigation Board, November 1999
Impact
Five dimensions, 0 to 10 each. The overall 6.0/10 is their average. How impact is scored
| Dimension | Score | Basis |
|---|
| Reach | 0 | No outside users |
|---|
| Duration | 10 | The orbiter was never recovered |
|---|
| Loss | 10 | The spacecraft was lost |
|---|
| Recovery | 10 | Nothing to repair once it was gone |
|---|
| Cascade | 0 | No spillover |
|---|
Mars Climate Orbiter loss, 1999. Duration: a 10-month trip, lost on arrival. 5 hops from the first change to the failure.
See this exhibit in the 3D hall