No. 010 · Cabinet of Wrong Numbers

Pounds, Meet Newtons

· a 10-month trip, lost on arrival

Impact 6.0/10

  1. 1Ground software reports thruster impulse in pound-force seconds
  2. 2Navigation software expects newton-seconds
  3. 3Every small trajectory correction is off by a factor of about 4.45
  4. 4Orbiter arrives far too low over Mars
  5. 5It is lost in the atmosphere ✕

Units belong in the interface contract, not in someone's head.

Source: NASA Mishap Investigation Board, November 1999

Impact

Five dimensions, 0 to 10 each. The overall 6.0/10 is their average. How impact is scored

Reach0Duration10Loss10Recovery10Cascade0
DimensionScoreBasis
Reach0No outside users
Duration10The orbiter was never recovered
Loss10The spacecraft was lost
Recovery10Nothing to repair once it was gone
Cascade0No spillover

Mars Climate Orbiter loss, 1999. Duration: a 10-month trip, lost on arrival. 5 hops from the first change to the failure.

See this exhibit in the 3D hall