No. 002 · Hall of Lost Packets

YouTube, Briefly Owned by Pakistan Telecom

· about 2 hours

Impact 2.8/10

  1. 1Pakistan Telecom is ordered to block YouTube domestically
  2. 2It announces a more specific route for YouTube's address block to do so
  3. 3Its upstream provider passes the announcement on to the rest of the internet
  4. 4Routers everywhere prefer the more specific route
  5. 5Most of the world's YouTube traffic heads into Pakistan and disappears ✕

BGP believes what it is told. Filter what your customers announce.

Source: RIPE NCC case study, 2008

Impact

Five dimensions, 0 to 10 each. The overall 2.8/10 is their average. How impact is scored

Reach6Duration4Loss0Recovery4Cascade0
DimensionScoreBasis
Reach6One product, users worldwide
Duration4YouTube's more specific routes took over after about 1.5 hours
Loss0None stated in the source
Recovery4YouTube announced more specific routes; the upstream withdrew the bad one
Cascade0Only YouTube traffic was affected

YouTube BGP hijack, February 2008. Duration: about 2 hours. 5 hops from the first change to the failure.

See this exhibit in the 3D hall